We'd like to thank the law student who kindly volunteered to write this blog for us to mark World Children's Day.
Since 2015, the Children’s Rights Alliance for England (CRAE) has been part of Just for Kids Law. Through advocacy, campaigning and legal support, we work to make sure children and young people can access justice and exercise their rights. CRAE works to make those rights real, particularly when the Government makes decisions that affect children’s lives.
On 20 November, we celebrate World Children’s Day, marking the adoption of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). It’s a chance to restate a simple principle: children’s rights must be considered in decisions that affect them. But more than three decades after the UK ratified the Convention, there is still much more to do.
A year after the Covid-19 Inquiry recommended making Child Rights Impact Assessments (CRIAs) a legal requirement, the Government has an opportunity to reconsider its rejection. That would be an important step towards making sure children’s rights are consistently considered before decisions are made.
What is a Child Rights Impact Assessment?
A CRIA is a practical way to check how proposed policies or laws could affect children’s rights. Using the UNCRC and its Optional Protocols as a guide, it helps decision-makers spot potential harm and consider how different groups of children could be affected.
CRIAs don’t guarantee every policy will be right, and they don’t remove the need for difficult decisions. They make sure the possible consequences for children are considered before decisions are made.
The UK Government is not currently legally required to carry out CRIAs. Departments can choose to use them, but this has led to an inconsistent approach. Even when decisions could have serious consequences for children, there is no legal guarantee their impact will be assessed.
What the pandemic taught us
The pandemic exposed the weaknesses of this approach.
The Covid-19 Inquiry’s Module 2 report highlighted the significant harm children suffered during lockdowns, especially those already disadvantaged. School closures and restrictions on contact disrupted their education and cut them off from friends and important sources of support. For many children, the measures deepened existing inequalities.
Yet no detailed assessments of the impact on children were carried out before decisions to close schools and impose restrictions. Reflecting on the pandemic, Jeremy Miles, former Counsel General for Wales, acknowledged the need to “establish an earlier pattern of formal impact assessments” if a similar crisis happened again. Michael Gove, then serving in the Cabinet, also acknowledged a failure to pay attention to the impact on children when making decisions.
This is the kind of failure CRIAs could help prevent. That’s why the Inquiry recommended making them a legal requirement.
Why optional assessments aren’t enough
The Government has previously argued that its existing commitments to children’s rights, alongside voluntary assessments, are enough. But the approach remains inconsistent. In April 2025, the Department for Education confirmed that it did not record how many assessments were prepared or published. Departments themselves decided whether to carry them out.
A general concern for children’s welfare is no substitute for properly assessing how decisions could affect them. Without this requirement, it is difficult to know whether children’s rights are being properly considered.
The pandemic showed why that matters. The UK committed to the UNCRC decades before Covid-19, yet children were still overlooked in some of the most important decisions made during the crisis.
Making children’s rights part of every decision
Despite this, the Government has resisted making CRIAs a legal requirement.
In February this year, Baroness Lister put forward Amendment 221 to the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill. Supported by 160 organisations, including CRAE, the amendment sought to require Ministers to prepare CRIAs for legislative and policy decisions.
The Government opposed the amendment, arguing that it was unnecessary given the UK’s existing commitments to the UNCRC. But those commitments were already in place when the failures identified by the Inquiry happened.
In its March 2026 response, the Government also argued that making CRIAs a legal requirement would not necessarily make things better for children. It warned that assessments could become a box-ticking exercise, rather than genuinely helping to shape decisions.
A law alone cannot guarantee better decisions. But the risk of poorly used checks is no reason to leave them optional. Instead, assessors need clear guidance and training to do this well. Making CRIAs a legal requirement would not tell the Government which policies to choose. It would mean it must consider how its decisions could affect children’s rights – not just sometimes, but every time.
Time to act on children’s rights
Civil society broadly supports making CRIAs a legal requirement. As well as the 160 organisations supporting Amendment 221, over 70 organisations have urged the Government to act on the Inquiry’s recommendation and put children’s rights at the centre of its decisions.
The Joint Committee on Human Rights has also backed action. In August this year, it recommended the Government consider mandatory CRIAs while working towards bringing the UNCRC into domestic law.
This World Children’s Day, the Government can act on the pandemic’s lessons. Bringing the UNCRC fully into domestic law remains the ultimate ambition. Making CRIAs a legal requirement would be an important step towards turning the UK’s commitments to children into practice.
The Government must now accept the Inquiry’s recommendation.
Do you want to hear all the latest updates from Just for Kids Law? Sign up to our newsletter below.